In my opinion, I think Gandhi is not
responsible for the tragic end of his eldest son, Harilal. This is because
Gandhi actually had given an advice and responsible to his eldest son, Harilal.
Gandhi wants his son stand on his own feet, that why he didn’t leave harta to
him. He wanted his son to become a responsible person.
It’s not Gandhi fault when Harilal had failed three times in exams. Gandhi also sent thirty Rupees every month to his son to pay his fee in exam. It Harilal’s fault when he had a tragic ending in this movie. After Harilal’s wife died, Gandhi invited his son to come with him to the Ashram to build new live but Harilal refused to follow him. Harilal did not stick to his decision. For example, he became a Muslim but he returned to Hinduism in the end. That why Harilal’s character is a person who easy to be cheated by people. The other party used advantages of Gandhi’s name to make a profit. For example, they used Harilal to use Gandhi’s name and build Hari-Bhai Company.
Harilal also swindled people for 30,000 Rupees. Actually, Gandhi wanted Harilal to stand on his own without depend on Gandhi’s name as a father. Harilal as a Gandhi’s son is guilty because he used an advantage of his father’s name. Gandhi didn’t give his son a formal education because he thought hard work, self-control, compassion, selfless service were the values no school could provide.
In conclusion, as a father, Gandhi knew what is better for his son. He wanted his son followed his step to fight for their country. What happened to Harilal is because of his fault. He himself had chosen a way for his fate.
It’s not Gandhi fault when Harilal had failed three times in exams. Gandhi also sent thirty Rupees every month to his son to pay his fee in exam. It Harilal’s fault when he had a tragic ending in this movie. After Harilal’s wife died, Gandhi invited his son to come with him to the Ashram to build new live but Harilal refused to follow him. Harilal did not stick to his decision. For example, he became a Muslim but he returned to Hinduism in the end. That why Harilal’s character is a person who easy to be cheated by people. The other party used advantages of Gandhi’s name to make a profit. For example, they used Harilal to use Gandhi’s name and build Hari-Bhai Company.
Harilal also swindled people for 30,000 Rupees. Actually, Gandhi wanted Harilal to stand on his own without depend on Gandhi’s name as a father. Harilal as a Gandhi’s son is guilty because he used an advantage of his father’s name. Gandhi didn’t give his son a formal education because he thought hard work, self-control, compassion, selfless service were the values no school could provide.
In conclusion, as a father, Gandhi knew what is better for his son. He wanted his son followed his step to fight for their country. What happened to Harilal is because of his fault. He himself had chosen a way for his fate.
Harilal didn't really get what his father was trying to apply on him which is sacrifice towards his nation.
ReplyDeletewhat i can say that, Harilal should't not treat his father like that although him can't face the truth that Gandhi his father. What his father say to him only for his future.
ReplyDeleteharilal must face it that his father is a great leader indian nation and he must be independence to get what he wants..
ReplyDelete